A Conversation About The Beta Band, And Other Things
by David Balfour & Jumana Farouky
 
I asked my two best friends in London, David Balfour and Jumana Farouky, if they wanted to separately contribute something to Under the Radar. Both of them had been to see UK shows by The Beta Band and Radiohead, and I thought maybe they could cover those. Instead I got this. Seemingly, Jumana and Dave had an internet chat from their respective London offices while on lunch break. Jumana works at Time Magazine, while Dave helps run the UK arm of teen website bolt.com. The subject of the conversation is the new Beta Band album, which I had asked Dave to review since he was the one who turned me onto the band in the first place. Of course, they also digress, read on:
Jumana: I spoke to Chris last night. I told him I wanted to pursue things, he said he wanted to but he needs to sort some stuff out first. Understandable.
David: He should just say YES.
Jumana: He basically said yes - but it's not like we're in love...yet. he's got to figure out how much this is going to hurt Jeff. Oh...well, with me and Chris there's definitely potential. At least from my end. To be completely honest, I tend to fall real hard real fast...but only for certain people. It's only happened to me twice before and both ended up in lengthy relationships.
David: Wow, that is wild. Your life is like a rollercoaster.
Jumana: Hardly. More like the Teacups ride.
David: Do you end up vomiting at the end?
Jumana: Exactly. That's the best part of a relationship, as far as I'm concerned. :)
David: (-_-)
Jumana: Racist.
David: What?
Jumana: You just drew a fat China man...racist.
David: Fuck off.
Jumana: Tee hee! Hey, aren’t we supposed to write that Radiohead review?
David: Oh yeah....or we could do a review of the beta band....which I have been listening to, and it just bores me. It’s like I can see it is meant to be good music, and it’s clever, but I just don’t get any emotion from it.
Jumana: Any what? Boners? Lyrics? Oh, emotion.
David: Its all rather flat.
Jumana: I definitely agree, but I feel like that’s kind of the point. Not the flat, but the non-emotion.
David: I don’t know.
Jumana: Like Weezer.
David: You think they are adopting an ironic stance?
Jumana: See, no I don’t, because it’s not as if the songs are about emotional things. If they WERE ...oh, phone call. Hold.
David: See the music is clever, and on paper it is all quite engaging... but it never flies, it never catches. It’s there, you know its clever, and like it, then its gone and you can hardly remember it.
Jumana: I actually find it really comforting. First on an obvious level - the vocals are quite soft, the music’s quite sedate, but it’s also quite intimate...but not in a Tori Amos kind of way, which makes me ill.
David: Hmm, I see what you mean. And I agree that is what they might have been going for. Certainly that is what was achieved on the King Biscuit Time Eps, but I don’t think they hit the mark here...the tunes just don’t stand up. And no matter how subtle a bands intentions are, people do not write tunes to be forgotten.
Jumana: And I reckon all the Beta Band fans would agree with you...we’re looking at it from two different angles, Hot Shots II being my first exposure.
David: Right......
Jumana: They were probably trying to find a way to reach more people - what’s wrong with that?
David: Nothing, but they reached a lot of people with the Three EPs. Dry the Rain was massive. It was like a great big hug, the kind of feeling where you close your eyes and all you feel is warm.
Jumana: But don’t you think that ‘Dry the Rain’ is more like the songs on ‘Hot Shots II’ than the rest of the EPs?
David: Hhhhhmmmmmmmm, not at all.
Jumana: No?
David: No, I think they are way different.
Jumana: I thought ‘Dry the Rain’ really stood out from EPs.
David: Really, how so?
Jumana: It was definitely the most ‘pop’ tune on there.
David: OK. What about ‘Inner Meat Me?’ And I am not even sure if pop is the right term... what do you mean when you say pop?
Jumana: Granted - but that song is a little too odd. I liked it, but thought it was trying too hard. I mean accessible, really. By pop, I mean accessible.
David: OK. Certainly most of the tracks of Beta Band are not umm accessible, but The Three EPs is really, I feel, much more accessible than Hot Shots II.
Jumana: Really?! I don’t agree at all...
David: Sure Hot Shots has shorter tracks, but they are all muted and slightly inverted.
Jumana: I found it so much easier to get into Hot Shots than the other stuff I listened to
David: Really? The Three EPs was much more welcoming. It was bright and happy. Hot Shots is cloaked in its own oversampling. I feel it’s hard to get the songs.
Jumana: True, but I felt like someone listening to Three EPs already had to have a certain, predetermined mind set. You had to already be introverted to really appreciate it. Not so with HS. Not that there’s anything wrong with that. I feel like those who aren’t regular navel-gazers could get into HS much more. It’s more fun, certainly darker than EPs, but more fun. If that makes sense.
David: I don’t think there is any fun on HS2 at all. Its all rather dull, and they don’t sound like they are digging it at all. Like, for instance, when they were in concert there were moments when you could tell that they just loved playing the tunes.
Jumana: Actually, I was surprised at how much more energetic they were live.
David: Yes, that is what originally attracted me, the sense of excited, enthusiastic, exploration of music. I get the sense that they no longer love what they are doing? But on stage that night, I could see they did (sometimes).
Jumana: But when you first heard EPs, did you really think they were being excited and enthusiastic? I got no excitement from EPs.
David: Really? I got this great sense of exploration, of testing and pushing both music and themselves. They were excited the potential of what they could do in a very simple way. Its not always the excitement of happiness.
Jumana: Yeah, I got that too...but in a very possessive way. Like they were creating their own little world and I wasn’t allowed in..
David: Sometimes it came across as energy of some who had discovered how to finally express their deep sadness in exactly the right way.
Jumana: See, I think that’s it...too much sadness. even the seemingly happy songs are about sadness. I just can’t listen to that for long.
David: But the new album isn’t really about anything but word play, with no emotional connection to the work to back up any of the sounds. Look what happened to Beck and ‘Midnite Vultures.’ It was hailed when it came out, now its pretty much seen as an empty and pastiched genre exercise.
Jumana: But the thing you liked about EPs is the experimental quality. Can’t you accept the idea that this is where experimentation led them? The Beta Band have found themselves and this is the result. I think that pisses you off.
David: Well... I am not sure they have settled. Though I do think it is interesting that they have followed a path and gotten here. I find that always really interesting and I respect it. Its just that I don’t think they have come with quality.
Jumana: I understand that if I look at it from your point of view. Like, if Radiohead had come out with Amnesiac first, THEN the Bends. We usually find that bands produce the accessible stuff first, then try to experiment.
David: WOW, the quality of the Bends is not even in the same league as HS2. Radiohead has tunes. Let me ask you do you see you self listening to HS2 in a years time?
Jumana: I’d have to say no. I mean, not NEVER, just not regularly.
David: I agree and that saddens me.
Jumana: Wait...I need to pee...
David: Cuz I do pull Three EPs, Beta Band, and King Biscuit Time off the shelf for an airing. Ok you can pee. So I am a disapointed fan.
David: Let me ask you another question’: If you had to knock the album what would say?
Jumana: If I had to knock the album I would say that it is, indeed, relatively shallow and not eclectic enough. The songs sound a lot alike. (Did you save all that Beta Band stuff so we can sent it to Mark?)
David: I still have it, just think inserting a bit about Radiohead gig
Jumana: Good idea. Can I go get lunch or do you still need me?
David: Lets do it after lunch
Jumana: Perfecto. Hey - did you hear the rumors about a terrorist attack on London today?
David: No, what is that?
Jumana: It's one of those friend-of-a-friend stories. some guy in New York dropped his wallet a few days ago. When a woman returned it to him he said, "Instead of a reward, I'll give you a tip: stay out of London on Oct. 11"
David: Rubbish, sooo rubbish
Jumana: Oh, I know. But it got some people a little tense around here.
David: Morons.
Jumana: Hey, we even got a call from a retired general who used to work in the defense dept. telling us to be careful. It's understandable everyone's jumpy - London is the most logical next target
David: Its okay to be careful. Hell its okay to scared. Its not okay to be a moron