Charlotte Gainsbourg
Stage Whisper
Elektra
Nov 08, 2011 Charlotte Gainsbourg
In both facets of her career, actress/singer Charlotte Gainsbourg has made a living bringing other people’s visions to life. Given her broad range of collaborators-which have included Air, Beck, Jarvis Cocker, and Neil Hannon-it makes sense that any collection of her music would sound a bit schizophrenic. To avoid outright auditory whiplash, Stage Whisper is wisely divided into two halves-unreleased songs and live versions of tracks from previous albums. However, it’s still a very uneven ride.
The majority of the previously unreleased songs find Gainsbourg successfully riding the vibe Goldfrapp tapped into with Headfirst-all breathy vocals and Italo disco attitude. But with Gainsbourg it’s all a matter of positioning, her voice not unlike the tofu of the musical world-soaking up the seasoning around her. The same spunk that carries “Terrible Angels” and turns “Paradisco” into an otherworldly treat simply sounds dated on 1980s faux folk-electro cut “Got to Let Go”-a song that would have been better suited to a Noah and the Whale album.
The most notable departure in the first half is “Memoir,” a guitar-driven collaboration with Villagers that was previously released as a 7”. The track leans heavily on Gainsbourg’s superb skills as a storyteller, and she sells the tale of a lost woman with breathtaking believability.
Alas, the same cannot be said for the second half of the album, a live rehash of tracks from 5:55 and IRM. Ultimately, Gainsbourg on stage proves what we’ve suspected all along: that she’s created her music career with studio magic. Live, her voice-so haunting when paired with Air’s delicate orchestrations, and so playful within Beck’s framework-simply falls flat. She exonerates herself nicely on the Bob Dylan cover “Just Like a Woman” (the song’s lilting structure works perfectly with her elaborate sing-speech). But the rock-based tracks of IRM are a stretch, as the sultry elements of Gainsbourg’s voice are stretched to an unbecoming shriek. It’s a nice try, but the collection proves that ultimately, Gainsbourg shines more in the studio than on the stage. (www.charlottegainsbourg.com)
Author rating: 5/10
Average reader rating: 340/10
Current Issue
Issue #72
Apr 19, 2024 Issue #72 - The ‘90s Issue with The Cardigans and Thurston Moore
Most Recent
- Under the Radar Announces The ’90s Issue with The Cardigans and Thurston Moore on the Covers (News) — The Cardigans, Thurston Moore, Sonic Youth, Garbage, The Cranberries, Pavement, Lisa Loeb, Supergrass, Spiritualized, Lush, Miki Berenyi, Miki Berenyi Trio, Emma Anderson, Hatchie, Ride, Slowdive, Velocity Girl, Penelope Spheeris, Terry Gilliam, Gus Van Sant, Ron Underwood, Kula Shaker, Salad, Foals, Semisonic, The Boo Radleys, Stereo MC’s, Pale Saints, Blonde Redhead, Sleater-Kinney, Cocteau Twins, Lucy Dacus, Alex Lahey, Horsegirl, Grandaddy, alt-J, Squid, The Natvral, Wolf Alice, Jess Williamson, Sunflower Bean, Orville Peck, Joel McHale
- 10 Best Songs of the Week: Fontaines D.C., Cassandra Jenkins, Loma, John Grant, and More (News) — Songs of the Week, Fontaines D.C., Cassandra Jenkins, Loma, John Grant, Good Looks, Hana Vu, Belle and Sebastian, Yannis & The Yaw, Strand of Oaks, Home Counties
- Fresh Shares New EP ‘Merch Girl’ (News) — Fresh
- Premiere: LOVECOLOR Shares New Video for “Crazy Love” (News) — LOVECOLOR
- Final Summer (Review) — Cloud Nothings
Comments
Submit your comment
There are no comments for this entry yet.