Justice League Dark #1

DC

Written by Peter Milligan; Art by Mikel Janin

Sep 28, 2011 Comic Books Web Exclusive

Justice League Dark #1 is a decent premise with a ridiculous title; a book with a beautiful cover (Ryan Sook!) and interior art that's quite inconsistent; and a storyline that tries to inject the classic DC Vertigo history and sensibilities into the fertile NuDCU. What we get is a book that pulls you this way and that, and we're not quite sure to what end. More

Supergirl #1

DC

Written by Michael Green and Mike Johnson; art by Mahmud Asrar

Sep 28, 2011 Comic Books Web Exclusive

Writer Jeph Loeb and artist Michael Turner already nicely reintroduced Supergirl into the DC Universe back in 2004 in Superman/Batman #8. That really wasn't that long ago, so it's curious that with the New 52, Supergirl is one of the characters they've decided to start from scratch with again. More

Catwoman #1

DC

Written by Judd Winick; art and cover by Guillem March

Sep 27, 2011 Comic Books Web Exclusive

Catwoman #1 gets the series off to a solid start, mainly due to the dynamic art by Guillem March, rather than the breezy and not overly complex story by Judd Winick. More

Birds of Prey #1

DC

Written by Duane Swierczynski; Art by Jesus Saiz

Sep 27, 2011 Comic Books Web Exclusive

While this book may not be as technically proficient as, say, the very good Wonder Woman #1, there is a lot to like in Birds of Prey #1.  More

Batman #1

DC

Written by Scott Snyder; Art by Greg Capullo & Jonathan Glapion; Colors by FCO Plascencia; Cover by Greg Capullo; Variant cover by Ethan Van Sciver

Sep 27, 2011 Comic Books Web Exclusive

Batman #1 comfortably sits alongside the relaunches Action ComicsAnimal ManBatwoman, Justice LeagueSwamp Thing, and Wonder Woman. It's one of the best examples that DC's New 52 relaunch is an out-and-out success.  More

Captain Atom #1

DC

Written by J.T. Krul; Art by Freddy Williams II

Sep 26, 2011 Comic Books Web Exclusive

As much as I was rather pleased to find that Kyle Higgins' Nightwing #1 was far better than his Deathstroke relaunch, I was pleasantly surprised with J.T. Krul's Captain Atom #1 in the face of his rather lackluster Green Arrow #1 from a few weeks ago.

Red Hood and the Outlaws #1

DC

Writer: Scott Lobdell; Artist: Kenneth Rocafort

Sep 25, 2011 Comic Books Web Exclusive

Red Hood and the Outlaws #1 is disappointing. Scott Lobdell employs strong and appropriate first-person narration from two different characters, which is a tricky thing to pull off. Kenneth Rocafort's art is sort of like '90s-style done right; it's very scratchy in parts, uses exaggerated proportions to its advantage, rather than to an annoying extent, and has lots of personality. And we have three strong, pre-existing DC characters as the main players and some pretty interesting brand new ideas. But there's one thing that makes this book just go off the rails. More

DC Universe Presents: Deadman #1

DC

Writer: Paul Jenkins; Artist: Bernard Chang

Sep 24, 2011 Comic Books Web Exclusive

DCU Presents: Deadman #1 nicely splits the difference between honoring what came before and going off in a new direction. More

Legion of Super-Heroes #1

DC

Written by Paul Levitz; Art by Francis Portela; Colors by Javier Mena; Letters by Pat Brosseau; Edited by Chris Conroy; Cover by Karl Kerschl

Sep 23, 2011 Comic Books Web Exclusive

There are at least 16 protagonists in the first issue of Legion of Super-Heroes and writer Paul Levitz (Adventure Comics) fails to make us care about most of them. It's not quite the train wreck of sloppy art and Michael Bay-esque action that was Legion Lost #1, but this story leaves much to be desired. More