Band of Horses: Why Are You OK (Interscope) Review | Under the Radar Magazine Under the Radar | Music Blog for the Indie Music Magazine
Wednesday, July 17th, 2024  

Band of Horses

Why Are You OK


Jun 24, 2016 Band of Horses Bookmark and Share

For a while after 2012’s Mirage Rock, Band of Horses’ awkward, uncomfortable attempt at the mainstream, it seemed possible that the album would be the band’s last artistic statement. Which given the excellence of their first two records (heck, I even like 80% of Infinite Arms) would have been a true shame for a band who seemed to be placing the need for commercial success ahead of quality. The future looked uncertain and long-term fans were fearful.

Why Are You OK is a significant improvement on that record, and a genuine allaying of such fears. Granted, it is still not at the levels that propelled 2006’s debut, Everything All the Time, and 2007’s sophomore effort, Cease to Begin, to the public consciousness, but it does sound like a band re-establishing what made itself vital in the first place. Many reviews have focused on Ben Bridwell’s collaboration with Grandaddy’s Jason Lytle as the central key factor around the album’s renewed energy and color but such emphasis is unfair on the band-as much as Lytle’s production sounds fresh and invigorating, the success of the record centers around Bridwell re-establishing the emotional connections from the songs. Opener “Dull Times/The Moon” is an immediate validation of thisambitious, slow-build and explosive without seeming over-burdened or wasteful. “Whatever, Wherever” is effortlessly pretty and “Throw My Mess” carries a Bright Eyes-style folk-rock charm. Even better is when J Mascis turns up on the vibrant, joyous “In a Drawer” but it is the minimal, perfectly-weighted emotional punch of “Barrel House” that impresses most hereBridwell at his most confessing and emotionally articulate.

It doesn’t always worklead single “Casual Party” and “Country Teen” veer dangerously close to MOR rock-by-numbers but conversely, the inclusion of the psychedelic soundscape that is “Hag” shows that Band of Horses are not averse to exploring new territory while consolidating their older, more familiar ground. And while Why Are You OK may struggle to match the specific peaks of some of their previous work, its consistency, cohesion, and variety of songcraft breathes new spark into the band’s flame and hints at a brighter, more expansive musical future. (

Author rating: 7/10

Rate this album
Average reader rating: 6/10


Submit your comment

Name Required

Email Required, will not be published


Remember my personal information
Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below:

There are no comments for this entry yet.