
Phantogram
Eyelid Movies
Barsuk
May 13, 2010 Web Exclusive
The Saratoga Springs, New York duo of Josh Carter (guitar) and Sarah Barthel (keys/vocals) delivers an impressive debut full of dark beat-driven electronic rock. Opener and lead single “Mouthful of Diamonds” unfolds like a night blooming flower with some truly excellent layered vocals from Barthel and a smooth, clean, almost country sounding guitar line from Carter. It’s followed by the album’s second single “When I’m Small,” a driving piece of 8-bit melodrama that grows more ambitious, almost anthematic, as the song moves along.
On the whole, Eyelid Movies is a brave record that isn’t afraid to embrace the past. Nearly every song contains a few endearing details such as the 1990s drum breakdown in “Turn It Off” or the distorted tape loop accents in “10,000 Claps.” Phantogram manages to combine a lot of familiar elements in a new, strikingly sexy way. It should be noted that Eyelid Movies owes a great deal to Portishead’s entire catalogue in terms of song structure, phrasing, and instrumentation. This might rub some folks the wrong way, but this album still manages a unique, cohesive sound that definitely merits investigation. It’s a perfect choice for fans of The XX, who, not coincidentally, Phantogram are opening for on most of a forthcoming U.S. tour. (www.myspace.com/phantogram)
Author rating: 7/10
Average reader rating: 9/10
Current Issue

Issue #74
Feb 28, 2025 Issue #74 - The Protest Issue with Kathleen Hanna and Bartees Strange
Most Recent
- Festival Preview: Glastonbury Festival 2025 (Review) —
- 10 Best Songs of the Week: CMAT, Nourished By Time, Goon, The Mary Onettes, and More (News) —
- Digital Cover Story: Shirley Manson of Garbage on “Let All That We Imagine Be the Light” (Interview) —
- Rivers of Nihil @ The Meadows, Brooklyn, US, June 20, 2025 (Review) —
- Pins and Needles (Review) —
Comments
Submit your comment
August 5th 2011
9:23am
This band sound awesome. The lyrics are fresh and the sound is tight and very clear to the ears. All round this band enters all the senses and creates a great sound that is long lasting!
April 16th 2012
1:17am
Your pics are splendid. I like the information, it makes your users fixed to your website. I’m a university student and I am now overwhelmed with term papers, hire dissertation writer research papers, book reports essays papers and other responsibilities. I truly want to write my own, personal works yet some help is often desired. I want to use solidwriters.com for my final buy dissertation challenge . I discovered them through google . Will keep you submitted on the outcomes.