Rogue Wave: Nightingale Floors (Vagrant) album review | Under the Radar Magazine Under the Radar | Music Blog for the Indie Music Magazine
Tuesday, May 28th, 2024  

Rogue Wave

Nightingale Floors


Jul 03, 2013 Rogue Wave Bookmark and Share

Rogue Wave has had a very “indie” careerfrom the band’s jangly, sensitive aesthetic and critical acclaim to its prevalence on television and film soundtracks and, unfortunately, relative anonymity to mainstream listeners. In other words, for a band of its caliber and songwriting prowess, its career arc has probably felt lackluster both to its members and their fans.

That, however, has not stopped the Oakland, Calif. quintet from amassing an impressive catalog of subtly sweet guitar pop, capped off most recently by Nightingale Floors, an impressive collection of somber yet optimistic songs about taking things as they come and accepting where you are. Singer and driving creative force Zach Rogue (aka Zach Schwartz) sounds peaceful and confident when he sings, “The gravity of career ambition never meant that much to me,” on the mid-tempo acoustic strummer “Figured It Out.” The song, and the record as a whole, finds Rogue dealing with the loss of his father, the fleeting nature of life, and being grateful for what you’ve got. His band isn’t as big as he may have wantedso what? He gets to make music for a living, and things are pretty good.

Surrounding that song, which serves as the record’s general thesis, Rogue and company explore pretty well trodden indie pop territory with nearly always-enjoyable results. “College” layers a twinkling guitar hook over fuzzed-out power chords, à la contemporaries Nada Surf. The sweeping opener “No Magnatone” employs a similar technique, with Rogue’s heavily effected vocals contributing to the grander production value. Tracks such as these, along with the pulsating “Siren’s Song” and dynamic space-pop of “Used to It,” are right in Rogue Wave’s wheelhouse as a rock band for the sensitive guy. While the lumbering closer “Everyone Wants to Be You” pulls on heartstrings but misses on impact, the up-tempo cuts allow you to pump your first after a quick stop on the way up to dry your eye.

It is unlikely that Nightingale will catapult the band into any kind of whirlwind successthere just isn’t much demand for thoughtful guitar pop these days, and this isn’t groundbreaking materialbut it does showcase a band that has stuck to its guns, honed its craft, and created something pleasing to show for it. Could be a lot worse. (

Author rating: 6.5/10

Rate this album
Average reader rating: 8/10


Submit your comment

Name Required

Email Required, will not be published


Remember my personal information
Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below:

There are no comments for this entry yet.