• Reviews

• All
• Music
• DVDs
• Live
• Cinema
• TV
• Books
• Comic Books
• Video Games

Mar 07, 2025 Web Exclusive By Matt the Raven

We are now 12 years removed from Hamilton Leithauser fronting post-punk icons The Walkmen (not including their brief 2023 reunion tour), so using them as any kind of measuring stick for what to expect on This Side of the Island is an exercise in futility. Plus, he has a few solo records under his belt to use as more valid comparisons. Unfortunately, nothing on his fourth solo effort quite measures up to the expectations forged by his successfully vibrant musical history.

Most have a soft spot for Leithauser’s voice—a raspy, world-weary croon—only he’s no longer shouting his pain from the rooftops, instead he’s serenading us from the countryside with the sun shining on his face and a cocktail in his hand. Leithauser’s vocals, while perhaps not as emotionally raw as in some of his previous work, remain a compelling presence. He delivers the lyrics with a seasoned confidence, even as the music itself occasionally falls short of his capabilities by sounding as if any edge The Walkmen had has been traded in for a homespun, back-porch charm. While hints of Leithauser’s quirky sensibilities occasionally surface, they’re fleeting and underdeveloped.

While the album’s shortcomings are undeniable, it’s not a complete misfire. This Side of the Island ‘s strength lies in its louder, faster moments. Leithauser’s presence shines through on the soulful “Burn the Boats,” while tracks such as “Knockin’ Heart” and “Happy Lights” possess a certain understated appeal and invite repeated listens with charming, up-tempo grooves, accompanied by expressive hooks and pleasant melodies.

There’s not much on This Side of the Island that is daring or new in terms of musical explorations, but the energetic vocals and Leithauser’s distinct delivery keeps the album afloat. The arrangements are never overly polished, creating a real ramble through the sonic countryside that is more suitable for a comfortable night at home rather than a night out or a new adventure. (www.hamiltonleithauser.com)

Author rating: 5.5/10