
Batgirl and the Birds of Prey Vol. 1: Who Is Oracle?
DC
May 04, 2017 DC Comics
In relaunching Birds of Prey, writers Julie Benson and Shawna Benson and artists Claire Roe and Roge Antonio have accomplished something rather elusive: honoring the characters’ past incarnations while moving them forward, all against the backdrop of whatever line-wide continuity changes have been enacted from on high. We wouldn’t be so bold as so say it’s as good as the classic Chuck Dixon—or Gail Simone—helmed Birds of Prey volumes—but Batgirl and the Birds of Prey Vol. 1 is right there in the same atmosphere with good action, meaningful friendships, and character growth and introspection.
The character of Barbara Gordon is problematic due to the emotional resonance she invokes with past and current incarnations: as Batgirl, as Oracle, as a devoted daughter. The first volume tackles this head on, and mostly succeeds. Maybe a little too ponderous, a little too inside Babs’ head as she wiffle-waffles about what each role means to her. We were most impressed with the handling of the other two protagonists. Black Canary was pitch-perfect, almost real in a way—her look was perfect, a non-costumed superhero that could just be that too-intriguing lady at the rock show. The way her personality was portrayed matched, struck a very genuine tone. Less successful, but just fine, was Huntress’ constant agro and tough-guy one-upsmanship, but holy heck we loved how a key component of her origin story was altered (no spoilers here), and how it fit into the main story.
Not groundbreaking, but wholly enjoyable—couldn’t ask for much more from a monthly DC title. (www.dccomics.com)
Author rating: 7/10
Average reader rating: 5/10
Current Issue

Issue #74
Feb 28, 2025 Issue #74 - The Protest Issue with Kathleen Hanna and Bartees Strange
Most Recent
- Samia Shares Final Single “Carousel” (News) —
- Pulp Announce September North American Tour Dates (News) —
- Sunflower Bean Release “There’s a Part I Can’t Get Back” (News) —
- Cockdust (Review) —
- The Cure Announce New Remix Album to Benefit War Child UK, Share Four Tet and Paul Oakenfold Remixes (News) —
Comments
Submit your comment
May 19th 2018
1:26am
As we all know that entertainment to body is very necessary so you can play online bejeweled 3 games here http://bejeweled3.co in the best quality and at different amazing levels. So, enjoy these games online directly without any type of sign up process.
May 23rd 2018
6:19am
The web browser we are sharing with you will help you to work smoothly and also the settings available in this browser are really advanced and safe. So without wasting time download free mozilla firefox.