The Expanse
SYFY, Mondays 10/9 Central
Dec 11, 2015
Issue #55 - November/December 2015 - EL VY
The Expanse is the long-awaited television adaptation of James S.A. Corey's space opera series of the same name. Corey's books, beginning with Leviathan Wakes (whose storyline comprises the bulk of season one), are something of a crossover phenomenon. They're wildly imaginative, pulse-pounding thrillers first, sprawling genre exemplars second. That is, they make die-hard sci-fi readers happy while offering new genre initiates a diverse world of complex, relatable characters facing palpable stakes every step of the way. Their richly detailed world, in the right hands, could yield sci-fi's very own Game of Thrones.
Which leads one to wonder what's (not) in the water at SyFy that this terrific outlier of a book became SyFy's next serviceable/forgettable show in space. The Expanse pilot is flat and expositional, drawing the rules and perimeters of a colonized solar system that spans Earth, Mars, and the Asteroid Belt without giving us any cause to care about who occupies it. The stakes of a potentially violent "tension between Earth and Mars" are abstract and unspecified. Thomas Jane as our sympathetic anti-hero Detective Josephus Miller does nothing to make us love or hate him, a push-pull that would have been valuable as the story progresses. And it's not likely his fault. The material as it's written introduces us to a list of his character traits (polyglot, drunk, fedora-wearing) rather than him (tender yet isolated, perceptive to a fault).
You've seen this show before. Nowhere is that more clear than during scenes on the Canterbury, the ice freighter starship manned by gorgeous blue-collar workers sporting gym-rat bodies and manicured stubble. Steven Strait plays Captain Jim Holden, a reluctant XO whose natural charisma is forced out by tragedy. This happens on paper without adequately pulling the viewer into the drama. Again, these feel less like actor limits than story ones, though it's disappointing to reiterate that these faults aren't in the source material.
All in all, The Expanse is a missed opportunity, at least based on the pilot. This could have been more appealing with a stylized visual approach or a novel tone but instead it's sci-fi-by-numbers. No nails are bitten and no tears are shed. If you want that, you'll have to crack open Corey's tomes. (www.syfy.com/theexpanse)
Author rating: 4/10
Average reader rating: 8/10
Most Recent
- Matt Berninger and Stephan Altman Share New Song “All I Want” (Featuring Julien Baker) (News) — Matt Berninger, Stephan Altman, The National, Julien Baker
- Juliana Hatfield Shares Video for New Song “Lost Ship” (News) — Juliana Hatfield
- The Beths Share Video for Cover of Judy Garland’s “Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas” (News) — The Beths
- Stream Charlotte Gainsbourg’s New EP, Including Two Previously Unreleased Songs (News) — Charlotte Gainsbourg
- The End: Graham Wright of Tokyo Police Club (Interview) — Tokyo Police Club, The End
Comments
Submit your comment
December 20th 2015
10:55am
Don’t know, for me the pilot was pretty interesting. It sets things up without spelling them, which is a nice change of pace from the shows that we get these days. The characters are archetypical for now, but interesting nonetheless. And having seen the first four episodes now, I must say that I’m absolutely blown away by the show.
December 21st 2015
9:49am
How is this even a review? It is just an assortment of bold claims with no examples and misleading statements… “sci-fi-by-numbers” what a load of pretentious garbage. 4/10 for the review and the site
February 4th 2017
9:07am
how are you allowed a critic review / voice. a bad score because it is not as good an adaption from the books as game of thrones. 4/10. please
May 21st 2017
11:00pm
You blew this one, lol